Google can stop believing in your website, and it won’t send you a memo when it does. There’s no alert, no email, no little red flag. Your rankings just quietly slide, and you’re left wondering what you did wrong.

In September 2026, Google’s John Mueller put that in plain English. Replying to a site owner on Bluesky, he said Google’s systems possibly lost faith in a site because of its older, mass-produced pages, and that winning that faith back takes time and significant effort. The culprit he had in mind? Programmatic SEO.

So what is it, is it always a problem, and what should you do if your site leans on it? Let’s get into it.

What is programmatic SEO?

Programmatic SEO is the practice of using a template and a dataset to generate large numbers of web pages automatically. Think “plumbers in [every suburb]”, “[product] vs [product]” for every combination, or a page for every possible keyword variation. One template, thousands of URLs.

It’s been popular for years because it promises scale without the cost of writing every page by hand. And with AI tools now able to churn out code and copy in minutes, it’s easier than ever to spin up a thousand pages before lunch. Which is exactly the problem.

What Google's John Mueller said about it

The site owner Mueller replied to had built pages by working through a huge list of domain names, technologies and attributes, generating every possible combination. Mueller’s reply read: 

“A lot of pages with ‘some’ value, but an overall picture that isn’t very exciting. Adding even more generated data doesn’t make the site more useful to people.”

His broader warning was that this approach often leads to a site that is spam, borderline spam, or simply low quality. It’s easy to produce lots of pages, he said, and hard to provide real value. He was careful to add that he wasn’t calling that particular site spam, but that Google’s systems may have lost faith in it based on its older pages, and that fixing it lies in showing real value over time.

None of this is new. Back in 2023 Mueller noted that programmatic SEO is often just “a fancy banner for spam”. What’s changed since then is the volume of AI-generated pages out there, and how bluntly Google is willing to say what it thinks about them.

What does "losing faith" actually mean?

Mueller didn’t spell out the mechanics, so here’s our interpretation rather than a Google statement: when a large share of your pages look thin or templated, Google’s systems can start treating the whole site with more suspicion. That’s why pages that were once perfectly good can now slide down alongside the mediocre ones.

Two things make this a bit of a bummer. Firstly, an algorithmic demotion is silent. A manual action from Google’s webspam team appears in Search Console, but a ranking decline caused by Google’s automated systems doesn’t come with a label. Secondly, there’s no fast fix. Mueller pointed to how long people spend recovering from spam and core update problems as a guide to the effort involved. Translation: it’s a marathon, not a quick plugin-fix.

Is all programmatic SEO bad?

No, and this is where a lot of the panic goes wrong. Google’s spam policy on scaled content abuse targets many pages generated mainly to manipulate rankings rather than help people. It applies however the content is made: AI, automation, humans, or a mix. Google’s own examples include using generative AI to create many pages without adding value, scraping or stitching together other people’s content, and pages that make little sense to a reader but are stuffed with search terms.

Notice what’s missing from that list: scale on its own. The policy is about purpose and value. A property portal with a page for every listing, or a product catalogue with genuine specs, pricing and reviews on every page, exists to help people. A thousand near-identical “best accountant in [town]” pages with the town name swapped out does not.

A simple gut-check: if you can’t explain what unique value each page offers that the others don’t, neither can Google.

Warning signs your site might be in trouble

None of these proves a problem on its own, because rankings drop for plenty of reasons. But several together are worth investigating:

  • Lots of near-identical pages. They differ only by a swapped keyword, location or product name.
  • Pages Google won’t index. Large numbers of URLs sitting in Search Console as “Crawled – currently not indexed” can mean Google doesn’t see enough value to keep them.
  • Indexed pages that get no traffic. If hundreds of pages exist and none ever earn a click, they’re probably dead weight.
  • A site-wide drop. Traffic falling broadly, rather than on one or two pages, after a core or spam update.

How to fix it

There’s no switch to flip, but there is a sensible process:

  1. Audit. List every templated page, then sort them by traffic, indexing status and whether they genuinely answer a question.
  2. Decide: improve, consolidate or remove. Improving means adding something real, such as original data, first-hand experience, genuine reviews or expert input. Padding with more generated text doesn’t count.
  3. Clean up properly. Redirect weak pages to a stronger, relevant page where one exists. Remove pages with no value and no equivalent. Use noindex for pages that must stay live for users but don’t belong in search.
  4. Check Search Console. Look under Security & Manual Actions. If there’s a manual action, fix the problem and submit a reconsideration request. If there isn’t, you’re dealing with an algorithmic issue, and the work is to improve and wait.
  5. Build trust back deliberately. Publish fewer, better pages, earn genuine mentions and reviews elsewhere, and be patient.

Why this matters for AI search too

This isn’t only about the classic ten blue links. Ahrefs’ analysis of 1.9 million AI Overview citations found that 76% also rank in the top 10 organic results, with a median position of 2. In other words, the pages AI Overviews quote are largely the pages Google already trusts. 

That’s our inference rather than a Google statement, but the logic is simple: if mass-produced pages drag your site down the rankings, you’re also less likely to be cited in AI answers. Trust compounds in both directions. 

We’ve said it before and we’ll say it again: Search engine optimisation and generative engine optimisation are very much intertwined.

Frequently asked questions

Q: Is programmatic SEO against Google’s guidelines?

A: Not by itself. Google’s spam policy targets scaled content abuse: many pages created mainly to manipulate rankings rather than help users, however they’re produced. Programmatic pages that offer genuine, unique value can be fine; thin, near-identical pages are the risk.

Q: What does it mean when Google “loses faith” in a site?

A: It’s John Mueller’s way of describing Google’s systems judging a site’s pages as low value. In practice that can mean lower rankings across the site, often without any notification, unless a manual action has been applied.

Q: How long does it take to recover?

A: Google doesn’t publish a timeline. Mueller said recovery takes time and significant effort to demonstrate real value, so plan in months rather than weeks.

Q: Can AI-generated content still rank?

A: Yes, if it genuinely helps people. Google’s policy applies however content is created, so the question isn’t whether AI wrote it, but whether the page adds real value.

The bottom line

Programmatic SEO isn’t the villain. Pages without a reason to exist are. Scale is easy; usefulness is the hard part, and it’s the part Google keeps getting better at spotting. If your site depends on thousands of templated pages, audit them now rather than waiting for a ranking drop to do it for you.

Not sure whether your site is building trust or burning it? That’s exactly the kind of website audit we do at We Do Digital. Get in touch.

Author

We Do Digital